A few successful examples do not establish an edge, especially when losing trades can be ignored or explained away after the fact. I would want a dated journal, consistent rules, realistic fees, and enough observations to understand drawdowns. What minimum evidence would make you comfortable testing this approach with small size? For a fair comparison, I would also track expectancy, average loss, maximum drawdown, and the number of trades rather than focusing on win rate alone. This matters because a high win rate can still hide poor risk control. In your experience, what specific rule or metric best separates disciplined use of this trading bots & automation topic from guesswork?